Rules Update: Superior Traits

  • Ardentfyre
  • Ardentfyre's Avatar
  • Elite Member
  • Elite Member
  • Posts: 732
  • Thank Yous: 25
14 Dec 2011 23:48 - 14 Dec 2011 23:49 #1 by Ardentfyre (Ardentfyre)
Rules Update: Superior Traits was created by Ardentfyre (Ardentfyre)
The New Dynamic of “Superior” Traits

With the re-writing of higher lists we are taking the opportunity to make a change in the difference between the Lower List skills and the Higher List skills. This difference is the “Superior” trait.  In general all new Offensive and Defensive skills on the higher lists will have the “Superior” trait.  Keep an eye on all new Higher List abilities to see whether they contain the Superior trait and assess how they function.

Superior attacks, can only be defended against by Superior defenses.  In practice what this will accomplish will be to bridge the gap between mid level and high level characters. It will also in general help to bring back a little bit of fear to the high level characters of the game. Overall they will need to be more aware of their position in battle, because any Superior attacks that target a 80th level character can only be blocked against by Superior defenses… the same number of Superior defenses that a 20th level character would have if they both maxed out.  

On top of this change, Higher Lists will also be broken up into paths that will force the players to make choices. Do you want to be a master warrior that focuses on offense or defense? This also in effect helps to make them more unique, so that not all master warriors are the same.

With this we will be more closely watching how monsters and encounters are sent out.  Random encounters should never have superior skills, unless very deliberately put out by staff for a purpose. Low levels should not have trolls break down their door and hit them with Superior attacks… however if low levels force themselves onto a high level mod, the error is theirs.  We are not promising any new formula, simply stating that we will adjust the way we send out NPCs to fit around this new game dynamic.

All in all we strongly believe this will be a very positive thing for the game environment and we hope that you will either immediately recognize the value of the change, or at the very least discover it and realize it for yourselves after a few months.

Lord Antrim Ardentfyre
    Order of the White Fox
        Master of Defense of the Mages Guild



[hr]
Jonathon G.
Rules Officer
Last edit: 14 Dec 2011 23:49 by .
15 Dec 2011 04:03 #2 by SlightlySaneBillliamm (SlightlySaneBillliamm)
Replied by SlightlySaneBillliamm (SlightlySaneBillliamm) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Since promotional skills are unique and usable once per event, will they be superior or remain lesser defenses?

"Slightly Sane Billliamm"

ooc: gene stern
15 Dec 2011 05:27 #3 by Alexandre Blythewood (Eleventh Phoenix)
Replied by Alexandre Blythewood (Eleventh Phoenix) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Can Nocturne of Undisturbed Dreams negate a superior attack?  (I assume the answer to this is no).

-Alexandre Blythewood

OOG: Zach Theis
  • Erdrick
  • Erdrick's Avatar
  • Platinum Member
  • Platinum Member
  • Posts: 2147
  • Thank Yous: 161
15 Dec 2011 07:14 #4 by Erdrick (Erdrick)
Replied by Erdrick (Erdrick) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits

Since promotional skills are unique and usable once per event, will they be superior or remain lesser defenses?


These will stay superior.

Lord Erdrick Brightstar
Guardian of Belladeen
(Samuel Roberts)
  • Matt D
  • Matt D's Avatar
  • Platinum Member
  • Platinum Member
  • Photographer extraordinaire!
  • Posts: 1998
  • Thank Yous: 557
15 Dec 2011 09:10 #5 by Matt D (MattD)
Replied by Matt D (MattD) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Can superior defenses also block non-superior attacks if needed?

Elias Ashby
Proprietor of the Ashby Family General Store

Lord Templar Rayven Nightwing of the Order of Holy Light

(OOG - Matt D. - Photographer)
  • Erdrick
  • Erdrick's Avatar
  • Platinum Member
  • Platinum Member
  • Posts: 2147
  • Thank Yous: 161
15 Dec 2011 09:15 #6 by Erdrick (Erdrick)
Replied by Erdrick (Erdrick) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Yes.

Lord Erdrick Brightstar
Guardian of Belladeen
(Samuel Roberts)
  • Gallion
  • Gallion's Avatar
  • Administrator
  • Administrator
  • Posts: 5566
  • Thank Yous: 2677
17 Dec 2011 08:35 #7 by Gallion (Gallion)
Replied by Gallion (Gallion) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
It is also worth mentioning that part of the plan is that tier 1 higher lists will be made much easier to learn. That is to say that their accessibility will be dramatically increased. No one should ever find themselves hopelessly stonewalled from learning them as the number of teachers for them will be far more abundant and diverse than they are currently.Tier one higher lists are the basics; master warrior,rouge,caster.



- James C. Kimball Director, Knight Realms
17 Dec 2011 09:55 #8 by Father Zahir al Nawar (Zahir)
Replied by Father Zahir al Nawar (Zahir) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits

Since promotional skills are unique and usable once per event, will they be superior or remain lesser defenses?


These will stay superior.


Since the smith promo is not a skill but an item and you can't obviously make the skills the item possess have the superior trait, do our items stay as is or will a single superior trait be included with them in some form or another?

Father Zahir ibn Hatim al Nawar
Priest of Brazen



oog: Chris Ayala;
Monster Marshall
  • Aleister
  • Aleister's Avatar
  • Administrator
  • Administrator
  • Posts: 3950
  • Thank Yous: 1504
17 Dec 2011 10:37 #9 by Aleister (Aleister)
Replied by Aleister (Aleister) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
The unique ability would more than likely be considered a Superior skill.

Lord Admiral Aleister Demirosz, the Phoenix


* * * * * * * *
-Steve Oros
Assistant Director
17 Dec 2011 13:09 - 17 Dec 2011 13:43 #10 by Father Zahir al Nawar (Zahir)
Replied by Father Zahir al Nawar (Zahir) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits

The unique ability would more than likely be considered a Superior skill.

Ah, so in my case, I'm boned. Gotcha.

Father Zahir ibn Hatim al Nawar
Priest of Brazen



oog: Chris Ayala;
Monster Marshall
Last edit: 17 Dec 2011 13:43 by .
  • geezer
  • geezer's Avatar
  • Platinum Member
  • Platinum Member
  • Posts: 4349
  • Thank Yous: 448
17 Dec 2011 20:20 #11 by geezer (geezer)
Replied by geezer (geezer) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
As promo skills are considered Superior, how is Holy Word handled when it is used to grant an attack which is not Superior?

Specifically, Holy Word - Blade of Victory

Edwin Haroldson
Loremaster
Master of the Mages' Guild

An ethical person does the right thing when no one is watching.

OOG - Charlie Spiegel - Kitchen Marshal

"War is a matter of vital importance to the State..."
  • Gallion
  • Gallion's Avatar
  • Administrator
  • Administrator
  • Posts: 5566
  • Thank Yous: 2677
17 Dec 2011 20:37 #12 by Gallion (Gallion)
Replied by Gallion (Gallion) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Holy word is not an attack or a defense. It is an augmentation. You huddle everyone together and still give out a dozen+ blade of victories. Blade of victory is non-superior.



- James C. Kimball Director, Knight Realms
  • Gallion
  • Gallion's Avatar
  • Administrator
  • Administrator
  • Posts: 5566
  • Thank Yous: 2677
17 Dec 2011 21:21 #13 by Gallion (Gallion)
Replied by Gallion (Gallion) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Im going to ask everyone to please refrain from sending me requests to turn the non-superior versions of your skills in magical items, into superior versions. We can always consider the possibility in the future, and if we do we will let you know, but for now, having superior skills exist in items sevearly reduces the effectiveness of what we are trying to do.

The concept of bridging the gap between 20th level characters and 80th level characters is based on the idea that they more or less both have access to the same number of superior defenses when maxed out in thier higher lists. If we open the pandoras box of allowing superior abilities into magical items, be they artifacts or not, we then open the door, for an 80th level character to once again have a lot more superior defenses than the 20th levels.

Currently the only superior skills that might be in items (however rare) are "Resist". For now we will probably allow these to be grandfathered, but under no circumstances will we be creating new items with "Resist"or allowing them to be created. We will be removing any ritual that allows valance to be placed into items.

Dodges, Stoneskin, etc, don't need to be changed from what they are, precisely because those skills still exist as they are. The only difference is that we have created new superior attacks that can bypass them. To balance that we have created new superior defenses, to stop those superior attacks.

Let me assure you also that we will take it slow over the next few events, warming everyone into this new dynamic. There will not be a lot of NPC superior attacks flying around, I also do not believe that there is any "Team Evil" around still that will try to PvP with this new dynamic in mind, so don't stress out about that either.





- James C. Kimball Director, Knight Realms
21 Dec 2011 18:06 #14 by Alexandre Blythewood (Eleventh Phoenix)
Replied by Alexandre Blythewood (Eleventh Phoenix) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Gypsy Death Curse specifies that only Resist Curse can defend against it.  Is GDC considered Superior, or is it a special case.

-Alexandre Blythewood

OOG: Zach Theis
21 Dec 2011 19:10 #15 by Draknar DoKanen (Draknar DoKanen)
Replied by Draknar DoKanen (Draknar DoKanen) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Its a special case because even Superior defenses don't block it.

Sean

Skimmel
RP Marshal, Rules Marshal, Storyteller
  • Janus
  • Janus's Avatar
  • Premium Member
  • Premium Member
  • Posts: 289
  • Thank Yous: 0
27 Dec 2011 11:17 #16 by Janus (Janus)
Replied by Janus (Janus) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Random question that I thought of the other day.  Are the dodge's that I get through the Exemplar ritual considered Superior cause they come from a Higher List or regular since they're just a dodge?

Janus Ivillious
Court Sorcerer of Winterdark

Every man has his own destiny: the only imperative is to follow it, to accept it, no matter where it leads him.

Mike Dennis

RP Marshal
27 Dec 2011 14:49 #17 by Woolsey Bysmor (Osred)
Replied by Woolsey Bysmor (Osred) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
The dodge is just a dodge. 

-OOG Michael Smith
07 Jan 2012 12:23 #18 by Winks Sharpthorn (Winks)
Replied by Winks Sharpthorn (Winks) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Along the same lines as Mike's question, would Ritual of Chrono Step be superior or remain a lower-list Dodge?

Random question I just thought of.

In Service to Travance
Ser Winks Sharpthorn, The Resolute
Knight of Drega'Mire
Soul-Blade of Galladel


Alt: William Sterling
Chief Mechanic of the Kormyrian Sky Flotilla
Lead Engineer of the Travancian Railroad

OOG: Walter Soto
Marshal
Cannon Marshal
  • Erdrick
  • Erdrick's Avatar
  • Platinum Member
  • Platinum Member
  • Posts: 2147
  • Thank Yous: 161
07 Jan 2012 15:28 #19 by Erdrick (Erdrick)
Replied by Erdrick (Erdrick) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Chrono step would likely be superior because all it does is a self castable defense.

Lord Erdrick Brightstar
Guardian of Belladeen
(Samuel Roberts)
  • Velius
  • Velius's Avatar
  • Senior Member
  • Senior Member
  • Never walk into a fair fight when walking into an unfair fight is an option.
  • Posts: 109
  • Thank Yous: 76
10 Jan 2012 21:29 #20 by Velius (Velius)
Replied by Velius (Velius) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Are you able to call intercept on a superior skill and take the attack for someone? On that note, can you combine intercept with a superior defense like Repel or Immaculate Defense, or would you have to use skills like Intercede?

__________________________________________________________
OOG: Drew C.

"I don't always NPC. But when I do, it's for years at a time."
  • Erdrick
  • Erdrick's Avatar
  • Platinum Member
  • Platinum Member
  • Posts: 2147
  • Thank Yous: 161
10 Jan 2012 21:34 #21 by Erdrick (Erdrick)
Replied by Erdrick (Erdrick) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
You may use a normal intercept to take the effect of a superior attack. From that point you can as well use a superior defense to defend against it.

Lord Erdrick Brightstar
Guardian of Belladeen
(Samuel Roberts)
  • Tim P
  • Tim P's Avatar
  • Elite Member
  • Elite Member
  • Posts: 720
  • Thank Yous: 379
13 Jan 2012 17:46 #22 by Tim P (OrganicGolem)
Replied by Tim P (OrganicGolem) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
Ritual of Fear says it gives you two uses of fear, and one 'terror'. Are either or both of these skills going to be superior?

[hr]
-Tim P
13 Jan 2012 18:24 #23 by Draknar DoKanen (Draknar DoKanen)
Replied by Draknar DoKanen (Draknar DoKanen) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
As of now there are no Superior mind effects, so no.

Sean

Skimmel
RP Marshal, Rules Marshal, Storyteller
  • Gallion
  • Gallion's Avatar
  • Administrator
  • Administrator
  • Posts: 5566
  • Thank Yous: 2677
14 Jan 2012 01:42 #24 by Gallion (Gallion)
Replied by Gallion (Gallion) on topic Rules Update: Superior Traits
As of right now, higher list abilities, that give you groups of abilities are not intended to be superior. For instance if there is a higher list transformation skill or ritual that gives you a set of stats, it is likely that non of those stats will be superior.



- James C. Kimball Director, Knight Realms
Moderators: Lois Heimdell (LoisMaxwell)
Time to create page: 0.647 seconds